Did Any thing That Roger Did Help The Band?

[justinpinkfloyd99]

Vote Now and see

[Nockster]

I have said this before and I will say it again...
Pink Floyd is a sum of it's parts, nor more, no less

[justinpinkfloyd99]

Yes I aggre that why I am not a big Pulse fan and I think that the alblums pink floyd made without roger waters are nothing compared to the origanal pink floyd. Because the good thing about seeing pink floyd back in the day is that you went to go see them and it is just the 4 of them. They never added any extra people. For example, Extra gutair insted of origanal bass a fill in and the drumer's different, ect. But with Pulse and Momentary Lapse tour there are like 10 extra people that they don't need. Well they do need guy pratt for bass but I don't think they need 2 drummers, 2 keybords, 2 gutarists.

[darksorrow]

in my opinion pink floyd went downhill without roger waters

[justinpinkfloyd99]

They are not the same with out him

[CorporalClegg-Box]

Floyd developed into a totally different band when Roger left. Remember the inner sleeve cover of AMLoR? David & Nick standing together and smiling. No Roger, no Rick: what a sad moment in the history of photography.

[SiMuLaCrUm]

Quite frankly, I don't like how the Floyd sounded after Rog left. It was missing something, and Gilmour isn't too good at writing lyrics in my opinion. The bassist Dave tours with now, Dave Pratt or something like that, just doesn't cover Rog's style very well.

[mastrangelo]

justinpinkfloyd99 you are right